EDINBURGH PREVIEW: Please post allmatch-related comment here
By The Saracens
December 8 2022
26th September 2020 - a day most Saracens’ supporters remember well. A time of COVID and uncertainty. Relegated to the Championship but with no prospect of competitive rugby there any time soon, Sarries are in limbo. COVID means that the final rounds of last season’s Heineken Cup remain to be played. Sarries have just done the impossible a week ago beating Leinster away from home to make it to the semi-final. A Sarries’ team shorn of the suspended Owen Farrell plus Lozowski, Isiekwe, Malins and Earl out on loan pulled off one of the most phenomenal wins in the club’s history to overcome the Irish champions in Dublin. But with just a week’s respite it is time to go again.
And this time the French giants Racing 92 lie in wait. Surely this raggle-taggle “not a proper” rugby team can’t go all the way? Racing, who beat a weakened Sarries team at La Defense Arena just after the punishment was announced only for Sarries to gain their revenge back at Allianz. Racing 92 triumphant away from home over the mighty Clermont in the quarters. Racing bursting with superstars: Juan Imhoff, Finn Russell, Simon Zebo, Teddy Thomas, Virimi Vakatowa, Camille Chat, Wenceslas Laurent, Maxime Machenaud, Francois Trinh-Duc: Sarries left with rag, tag and bobtail. And it is all so very close with injuries to Duncan Taylor and more importantly Brad Barritt instrumental in a heart-breaking last minute Racing try to take the victory. The European fairy tale is over and now The Wicked Witch of The West was in control. Who knows when, or even if, Sarries will be back.
Fast forward to this Sunday and it all begins again. How we’ve missed the opportunity to pit ourselves against Europe’s finest. For once the cards have fallen kindly for Sarries. The sad demise of Wuss and Wasps has meant 2 weeks off for much of the team and even the survivors of Yoda’s suspect regime have been able to have a week’s break. Our visitors on Sunday are Edinburgh. So far they have had an indifferent season winning 4 and losing 5 which places them 6th in the United Rugby Championship (which incidentally mirrors the Premiership with Leinster on top, 9 out of 9). More importantly, it appears that defeat to Munster last weekend has also cost them the services of Darcy Graham who has been in sparkling form of late and Chris Dean. Edinburgh still boast some talent though including WP Nel at tighthead, former Chief’s lock Sam Skinner, along with former Sarrie Nick Auterac and talented backs Emiliano Boffelli, James Laing, Blair Kinghorn and Duhan Van Der Merwe.
Both teams will undoubtedly be as strong as possible - Mark McCall and Mike Blair have said as much. Both teams will want to lay down a marker in this rather strange incarnation of the Heineken Cup:- 4 pool games in 2 leagues of 12 to eliminate 8 clubs then straight into the last 16 with a one off knockout game so home advantage and a good seeding will be all important.
Rumour has it that Marco Riccioni is fit (after that rather worrying knee injury against Saints) and Nick Isiekwe also appears ready to return. Theo’s injury seems less serious than first thought so hopefully our injury crisis is starting to abate. I assume we will go with something like:
Mako, George, Riccioni, Itoje, Hunter-Hill, Theo, Earl, Billy, Van Zyl, Farrell, Maitland/Malins, Tompkins, Lozowski, Daly, Goode. With Potentially a much stronger bench than recently, Sarries should be in good shape.
Surely the might of the Premiership Leaders will be too much for Edinburgh but let us not forget, the men from North of the Border triumphed on their most recent visit to Barnet in last season’s Challenge Cup. I don’t think that will happen again however Sarries often struggle a bit with cohesion after a break - let’s hope they’re all in harmony come Sunday.
The referee is a new one on me: Nika Amashukeli from Georgia assisted by Vincent Blasco Baque and David Beun with Eric Gauzins in the truck (all 3 french). (Update – it seems Nika is a rising star of the Rugby Referee world. He was forced to retire from playing the game at the age of 20 following ankle and knee injuries and several bouts of concussion. He is just 27 and hails from Tbilisi. He was inspired to become a referee having watched Wayne Barnes and took part in a Referee exchange programme between Georgia and the IFRU, gaining experience in the All-Ireland League. He became the first Georgian referee to officiate at a tier 1 International when he took charge of Wales v Canada and later Ireland v Italy and Ireland v Japan in 2021. He was awarded Ireland v South Africa this autumn and seems to have done OK given the complete lack of comment about him! Let’s hope that is the case on Sunday!
Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 2022:12:21:19:25:05 by Darraghgirl.
Do wonder when we’ll see Eduardo Bello. He certainly has the pedigree and there’s no sense risking Riccioni unless he’s 100%
Quote:The Bard
Do wonder when we’ll see Eduardo Bello. He certainly has the pedigree and there’s no sense risking Riccioni unless he’s 100%
EB was injured in one of the early PRC matches. Does anyone know the extent of this and if he is still crocked?
1 Mako Vunipola
2 Jamie George
3 Marco Riccioni
4 Maro Itoje
5 Hugh Tizard
6 Theo McFarland
7 Ben Earl
8 Billy Vunipola
9 Ivan van Zyl
10 Owen Farrell (c)
11 Sean Maitland
12 Nick Tompkins
13 Alex Lozowski
14 Alex Lewington
15 Elliot Daly
Replacements:
16 Tom Woolstencroft
17 Eroni Mawi
18 Alec Clarey
19 Callum Hunter-Hill
20 Andy Christie
21 Jackson Wray
22 Aled Davies
23 Alex Goode
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2022:12:09:12:05:24 by LutonS.
15. Emiliano Boffelli (22)
14. Wes Goosen (4)
13. Mark Bennett (76)
12. James Lang (26)
11. Duhan van der Merwe (69)
10. Blair Kinghorn (124)
9. Ben Vellacott (26)
1. Pierre Schoeman (89)
2. Stuart McInally (170)
3. Luan de Bruin (15)
4. Jamie Hodgson (46)
5. Grant Gilchrist (180)
6. Jamie Ritchie (89)
7. Luke Crosbie (77)
8. Viliame Mata (102)
Replacements
16. Patrick Harrison (8)
17. Boan Venter (34)
18. WP Nel (178)
19. Marshall Sykes (29)
20. Ben Muncaster (22)
21. Charlie Shiel (48)
22. Charlie Savala (19)
23. Damien Hoyland (99)
Quote:TommyKentish
Just Isiekwe and Malins missing. Maybe missing Bello on the bench too but bloody good lineup.
And Roti. He gets better each time he plays. Hope to see him back in a squad sometime soon.
Quote:Indeed, and even more valuable is Lozo who covers every back position on his own!Duncan96
That bench shows how valuable Eliot Daly and Alex Goode are. All back positions covered by 2 players.
Quote:one fine day
Jack of.. master of. And we still need a Scrummie to match the talents of the rest of the team. Who/ when was the last "9" that came through our academy ?
I would claim that Daly is a masterful winger, centre and full back and that Alex is a masterful full back and fly half. And, as mentioned above we have Loz who is masterful at centre and, last season, also at fly half. With modern squads/salary caps these types of players are more valuable than ever.
I think Charlie Bracken will emerge over time as a first team 9. Did Ben Spencer come through the academy? If so I think he was the last. A big loss but unavoidable.
Our last scrum half to come through the entire development pathway in our area and play in the league for us was Luke Baldwin (briefly) a decade ago.
We have NEVER had a scrum half come through youth rugby, the senior academy, and establish themselves in a league 23 in professional rugby. Ben Spencer is obviously the closest thing to that
Quote:Don’t say I didn’t warn you!The Bard
I really wouldn’t underestimate Edinburgh. They had done very little last season before beating us and although we nearly snatched it at the end could have no complaints.
Owen, Maro and Theo a long way from their best.
Topics oj has become a very accomplished presented. He brings knowledge of the game with clear balance points of view.
But for some reason the picture quality was not as good as b.t sport s
We gave away far to many penalties and didnt seem to grasp the ref would ping us if we didnt release on the floor, bit slow. Team seemed rusty as could have been expected and left some glaring holes in heir defence which Edinburgh gratefully ran through. I thought they looked a good side but its been way too long since we played together, I’m sure next week’s performance will be a step upwards
Quote:My thoughts too, although others around me disagreed.Roger G
Given how the game had gone I really didn't understand why we went for the corner with a couple of minutes to go. One thing we had done well was secure the restart, so 3 points and a 7 point lead would have guaranteed at least a draw plus try bonus point with little risk of losing the game. Going for the corner opened the door for an Edinburgh win, which they nearly took.
Didn’t the same thing happen against Bristol at Spurs?
I’ve seen Boffelli play 3 times now and he hasn’t missed a kick.
Quote:Roger G
Given how the game had gone I really didn't understand why we went for the corner with a couple of minutes to go. One thing we had done well was secure the restart, so 3 points and a 7 point lead would have guaranteed at least a draw plus try bonus point with little risk of losing the game. Going for the corner opened the door for an Edinburgh win, which they nearly took.
I think that at that precise moment Edinburgh only had 13 players on the pitch so a kick to the corner to score 7 and take the game out of reach was a sensible option. We simply didn’t execute the catch and drive very well though and gave a penalty away and then they were back to 14 and we were defending again!
next week will be the acid test.....
Ninjafez - supporting Sarries and cleaning their signs since 2006!
