Me and Sir – A Mutually Parasitic Relationship
Posted by: ComeOnYouSaints.com (IP Logged)
Date: 31 December, 2009 01:03

What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.

Re: Me and Sir – A Mutually Parasitic Relationship
Posted by: Shaddo (IP Logged)
Date: 31 December, 2009 06:59

A very good essay Master Flatt. Thankyou.

Re: Me and Sir – A Mutually Parasitic Relationship
Posted by: St.Rich Joe, Niamh and Sam's Dad (IP Logged)
Date: 31 December, 2009 07:23

Very nice flattie



No alcohol for January. I'm a dryathlete in aid of cancer research.

Dryathlon

Re: Me and Sir – A Mutually Parasitic Relationship
Posted by: St Francis (IP Logged)
Date: 31 December, 2009 08:46

Jolly well written sir... I read it all the way to the end!

Re: Me and Sir – A Mutually Parasitic Relationship
Posted by: SAINT_aitch (IP Logged)
Date: 31 December, 2009 08:48

Hmm, a good read Mr Flatt and very thought provoking. I would say though that perhaps you are expecting a little too much from Sir(s) given the number of, and possible interpretation of the many laws they have to apply at any one time in a game. Admittedly they have the AR's, who, I agree with you, should have greater influence on the game and express themselves more during a game, but overall this only works if all officials are trained, and govern with equal understanding of the laws and how/when to apply them.
I think your 'gripe' (for want of a better word) will never be resolved as long as the game is so difficult to officiate as a result of these points.
Who would be a referee eh?

Re: Me and Sir – A Mutually Parasitic Relationship
Posted by: Ian Spokes (IP Logged)
Date: 31 December, 2009 08:54

That's a very complex subject to tackle Paul, so well done for making it interesting,and thank you.

It always seems to me that the core problem (for afficionados and particularly newcomers to the game) is that the laws are just too complicated. But then, whenever the tinkerers tinker in (presumably) an effort to improve and simplify they just seem to make it all worse.

As you suggest, whether the laws are sensible or daft, refereeing consistency is one aspect that could and should be addressed. At the top level much of the match preparation depends on who Sir is going to be next Saturday because that will dictate how the laws will be interpreted and thus has an influence on the way the game is played. That cannot be right - distorting our sporting entertainment even before kick off.

We have full time referees in the GP now. I suggest that a good starting point would be to have them all working together in the same location for most of the week - physical training / testing, performance analysis etc. The fact that they did all this together and would therefore be talking to each other might just help them to get on the same hymn sheet.

I must add though, that it is very rare indeed for me make any comment about the officials. after a game. Clearly some are better than others but the old adage that without them there would be no match at all still holds. It is - at the level we mostly watch - an incredibly diffcult job, with complicated laws, played at high pace by practiced pros in front of passionate tribes of supporters. I wouldn't want to and couldn't do it.

Apologies - post becoming longer than the original article.

Re: Me and Sir – A Mutually Parasitic Relationship
Posted by: ClaireJ (IP Logged)
Date: 31 December, 2009 08:56

Nice article Mr Flatt - a bit harsh complaining about lost contact lenses! It's bloomin' awkward having mixed blurred and clear sight. I always worry when they are putting them in with a muddy finger.

I think there are effective ARs - Bruce Robertson for one. He is from your school of letting the game flow and when the play breaks making sure the ref know what's gone on.

Re: Me and Sir – A Mutually Parasitic Relationship
Posted by: Thrupp artist (IP Logged)
Date: 31 December, 2009 09:50

I enjoyed that - a thought provoking dissertation.

Re: Me and Sir – A Mutually Parasitic Relationship
Posted by: OldPete (IP Logged)
Date: 31 December, 2009 10:02

a star is born - well done Paul.

Re: Me and Sir – A Mutually Parasitic Relationship
Posted by: Eif Jones (IP Logged)
Date: 31 December, 2009 10:34

One of the beauties of the game is that every referee is different, the players find that out in that first 10 minutes.

I've mentioned this before but Rupert Moon, when he retired from playing, took up refereeing and gave up after one season, why, because he found it impossible to decide which offence to penalise. That's why consistency is an unachievable goal, each referee has his own view as to which offence to penalise. There was a typical situation in the recent Worcs game, a Worcs player did something wrong on the ground, simultaneously a Saints player had come in on the side, maybe the root cause of the Worcs offence or maybe not, which penalty does 'sir' give. The problem occurs when the same team get the majority of these 50/50 calls, one of the benefits of playing at home.

Re: Me and Sir – A Mutually Parasitic Relationship
Posted by: smurfomatic (IP Logged)
Date: 31 December, 2009 10:48

Flattie - I agree with the idea of having a "team" of officials together for a season (also they should rotate who is the referee to give the assistants experience) but how will they be evaluated in the "refs society" if no-one else is watching their performances (like an assessor)? Surely when the complaint comes in that Mr Ref missed this, that or the other, his assistants could well close ranks if it's not on video?



Photo Gallery

Re: Me and Sir – A Mutually Parasitic Relationship
Posted by: Saint Dom in Hanoi (IP Logged)
Date: 31 December, 2009 10:57

Spleen well and truly vented, then Paul?!

The sad reality is that most whistlers would probably agree with you and might even buy you a pint after reading this (essentially sympathetic) diatribe. But their problem is always the same one: there are 31 players on the pitch and only one of them is not trying to cheat.

Although rugby has been professional for over a decade, I think the game is still in a transitional state. There is so much at stake and it is still a collision sport - like boxing and wrestling rolled into one muddy spectacle, but with many more participants. And professionalism has had the effect of transforming the erstwhile 'gentlemen' into the 'hooligans' of the old saying.

I think the man in the middle does the best he can with his 2 eyes and his assistants, but the real responsibility lies with the cheats, who get more and more clever each season.

They are the ones who should change their ways to save the game, but they won't, will they?

Re: Me and Sir – A Mutually Parasitic Relationship
Posted by: Cg (IP Logged)
Date: 31 December, 2009 11:07

Very good Mr Flatt.

Re: Me and Sir – A Mutually Parasitic Relationship
Posted by: Clive Norling (The First) (IP Logged)
Date: 31 December, 2009 11:19

Mr. Flatt ....

A very entertaining and well written article ....

I hope we can renew our aquaintance on Monday 4th Jan, 2010!

Re: Me and Sir – A Mutually Parasitic Relationship
Posted by: Paul Flatt (IP Logged)
Date: 31 December, 2009 11:24

A few chips can open a thousand doors, Clive.....



"Your days are numbered. Use them to throw open the windows of your soul to the sun. If you do not, the sun will soon set, and you with it."

-- Marcus Aurelius, Roman Emperor 161-180 A.D.

Re: Me and Sir – A Mutually Parasitic Relationship
Posted by: Bob Stainsby (IP Logged)
Date: 31 December, 2009 13:03

Thank you Paul well written a subject (like reffing itself) that I wouldn't want to take up. I think in a nutshhell your saying waht we all want I.E. Firmness, Fairness, Consistency (among all refs) and proffesionalism.



Top of the League 2014-2015 Season

Re: Me and Sir – A Mutually Parasitic Relationship
Posted by: Howlin (IP Logged)
Date: 31 December, 2009 13:50

Thought provoking and sympathetic. Thanks for that. Part of me still clings to the doctrine that sir is always right and beyong reproach, the game has been served generally pretty well by this over the years. There is still a nagging doubt however that as the game develops more pressure is on the officials to up their game. Perhaps the key is materiality, why were most games officiated by Spreaders free flowing and entertaining whilst other whiste blowers may not be able to make this claim ? However with materiality comes subjectivity and consistency can never be achieved whilst that prevails. An unanswerable question ? But certainly worth the debate.



Saint til I die

Re: Me and Sir – A Mutually Parasitic Relationship
Posted by: Robby Richmond (IP Logged)
Date: 31 December, 2009 23:21

i thought it was Robert Jones Eif?

a fine read flattie, kudos to you..

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net