News: My Perfect Cousin?
Posted by: ComeOnYouSaints.com (IP Logged)
Date: 15 July, 2010 14:19
What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.
Re: News: My Perfect Cousin?
Posted by: Stockers (IP Logged)
Date: 15 July, 2010 14:51
Well wrote Sir!
One thing rugby union can learn from soccer, in particular the FIFA World Cup..... ban vuvuzelas!
One thing rugby union can learn from soccer, in particular the FIFA World Cup..... ban vuvuzelas!
Re: News: My Perfect Cousin?
Posted by: ChrisG (IP Logged)
Date: 15 July, 2010 15:26
But me and Kevin we're just not the same!
(Good stuff Phil)
(Good stuff Phil)
Re: News: My Perfect Cousin?
Posted by: Mattysaint (IP Logged)
Date: 15 July, 2010 15:48
The national football team doesn't play at the same time as the club sides. Can you imagine what Ferguson would be like if England started taking Rooney away in November, February and March to play in a series of internationals while United were fighting for the league title?
Flip side is you can't have it boths ways and which do you prefer to have priority - club or country? Premiership title or World Cup?
Flip side is you can't have it boths ways and which do you prefer to have priority - club or country? Premiership title or World Cup?
Re: News: My Perfect Cousin?
Posted by: Howlin (IP Logged)
Date: 15 July, 2010 16:33
Nice one Phil. Echoes most of my thoughts whilst watching teh WC. One more I had thought of is this.
There does appear to be so much more play acting in football now than when I used to watch it more regularly. The players get so good at it leaping in the air at the merest contact and sometimes when there is no contact at all. Sadly for me the winning team weere one of the worst offenders and they got away scot free.
It is so difficult to spot in real time so the referees have an impossible task. But often when the replay was shown it could be clearly seen that there had been play acting.
A possible answer would be a citing officer. Review after the match and hand out bans and fines to offenders. Might help prevent what I feel is one of the biggest blights on the game.
Saint til I die
There does appear to be so much more play acting in football now than when I used to watch it more regularly. The players get so good at it leaping in the air at the merest contact and sometimes when there is no contact at all. Sadly for me the winning team weere one of the worst offenders and they got away scot free.
It is so difficult to spot in real time so the referees have an impossible task. But often when the replay was shown it could be clearly seen that there had been play acting.
A possible answer would be a citing officer. Review after the match and hand out bans and fines to offenders. Might help prevent what I feel is one of the biggest blights on the game.
Saint til I die
Re: News: My Perfect Cousin?
Posted by: Shaddo (IP Logged)
Date: 15 July, 2010 17:06
My feelings precisely Howlin. A one year ban with no pay for offenders would soon stop the play-acting.
Re: News: My Perfect Cousin?
Posted by: Phil. (IP Logged)
Date: 15 July, 2010 17:13
Quote:Mattysaint
The national football team doesn't play at the same time as the club sides. Can you imagine what Ferguson would be like if England started taking Rooney away in November, February and March to play in a series of internationals while United were fighting for the league title?
Flip side is you can't have it boths ways and which do you prefer to have priority - club or country? Premiership title or World Cup?
Ah, but the Premiership (RU) has the play-offs which means that it is not imperative to finish top of the pile at the end of the regular season. Well done, Chelsea, you have finished top but now you have to play Spurs for the right to play the winners of Utd or Arsenal for the title. Can't see that happening...
Re: News: My Perfect Cousin?
Posted by: Stockers (IP Logged)
Date: 15 July, 2010 17:13
Quote:Howlin said,
A possible answer would be a citing officer. Review after the match and hand out bans and fines to offenders. Might help prevent what I feel is one of the biggest blights on the game.
Very good idea Malc but can you just imagine the lawyers for the overpaid prima donnas jumping up and down with un-righteous indignation when the citing officer sent in his report. The subsequent uproar would be worse than a Scouse wedding!!
Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 15/07/2010 17:15 by Stockers.
Re: News: My Perfect Cousin?
Posted by: OldPete (IP Logged)
Date: 15 July, 2010 18:16
One thing that I noticed was whereas in a tv rugby commentary on a prem match - barnes and co never shut up about who has , could and should play for england
In the soccer world cup it was all about who was going to or was leaving which premiershgip soccer teams.
In the soccer world cup it was all about who was going to or was leaving which premiershgip soccer teams.
Re: News: My Perfect Cousin?
Posted by: Ginger Prince in Stockholm (IP Logged)
Date: 15 July, 2010 18:46
Phil, great piece, and to answer 2 points if i may please.
The "was it a goal or wasn't argument" can be solved without the use of video evidence. Follow ice hockeys' example with a light on top of the goal. When the puck breaks the planes of the goal line, posts and cross-bar, the light is illuminated. sensors in the posts detect the passing of ONLY the puck over the goal line. The technology exists to change the sensors to recognise the shape and density of a football, as it's already been developed for one sport.
The reason i choose this is because i have to ask at what point do you blow the whistle and call time off? The ball is technically still in play,and no foul has occured, plus one team loses the advantage of possession...
If England were awarded a re-start, where would it be from and how many german players would now be behind the ball and able to defend?
Then, how do you re-start the game? drop ball from where? Maybe the germans were in counter-attack mode with so many english in advanced positions - they're penalised whilst the officials "go upstairs".
The beauty of the TMO in rugby is that when it's used, the passage of play is dead, i.e. the ball is over the line.
In football, you're wanting to stop a game when the ball is still in play and that's where the real arguments will start...
With regards to the equivalent of the penalty try, you're talking too much common sense for that idea to be taken seriously.
Soccer has addressed the cheats charter in this instance by saying in their laws that if the ball has not crossed the line, it's a penalty kick and a red card for the perpetrator. If the ball HAS crossed the line, it's a goal and a yellow card.
They see those sanctions,i.e. denying a clear scoring OPPORTUNITY as a red card offence, as justice. I agree with you, i'd like to see the goal (in instances like that) being awarded and a red card as well. The problem is managers would reach a state of apoplexy in an instant - they'd see it as a double punishment...
Ginger - The Colour of Sexual Rejection
The "was it a goal or wasn't argument" can be solved without the use of video evidence. Follow ice hockeys' example with a light on top of the goal. When the puck breaks the planes of the goal line, posts and cross-bar, the light is illuminated. sensors in the posts detect the passing of ONLY the puck over the goal line. The technology exists to change the sensors to recognise the shape and density of a football, as it's already been developed for one sport.
The reason i choose this is because i have to ask at what point do you blow the whistle and call time off? The ball is technically still in play,and no foul has occured, plus one team loses the advantage of possession...
If England were awarded a re-start, where would it be from and how many german players would now be behind the ball and able to defend?
Then, how do you re-start the game? drop ball from where? Maybe the germans were in counter-attack mode with so many english in advanced positions - they're penalised whilst the officials "go upstairs".
The beauty of the TMO in rugby is that when it's used, the passage of play is dead, i.e. the ball is over the line.
In football, you're wanting to stop a game when the ball is still in play and that's where the real arguments will start...
With regards to the equivalent of the penalty try, you're talking too much common sense for that idea to be taken seriously.
Soccer has addressed the cheats charter in this instance by saying in their laws that if the ball has not crossed the line, it's a penalty kick and a red card for the perpetrator. If the ball HAS crossed the line, it's a goal and a yellow card.
They see those sanctions,i.e. denying a clear scoring OPPORTUNITY as a red card offence, as justice. I agree with you, i'd like to see the goal (in instances like that) being awarded and a red card as well. The problem is managers would reach a state of apoplexy in an instant - they'd see it as a double punishment...
Ginger - The Colour of Sexual Rejection
Re: News: My Perfect Cousin?
Posted by: St Marlowe (IP Logged)
Date: 15 July, 2010 18:50
Quote:GP
they'd see it as a double punishment...
But that's only half what they deserve!
Good Piece Phil
David L
What if there were no hypothetical questions?
- Live wrong and preposterously
Re: News: My Perfect Cousin?
Posted by: StBleach (IP Logged)
Date: 15 July, 2010 19:29
I like the idea of the 'penalty goal ' - good article Phil.enjoyed reading that
Re: News: My Perfect Cousin?
Posted by: Howlin (IP Logged)
Date: 15 July, 2010 21:21
I don't disagree Stockers but i feel the sport has to take a stand. Possibly a lesson rugby can learn from football is don't let things get that far. The three Ms rule football Money, (big) Mouths and the Media.
Saint til I die
Saint til I die
Re: News: My Perfect Cousin?
Posted by: ChrisG (IP Logged)
Date: 15 July, 2010 21:39
Caught the end of one of the GAA games over the weekend, you think footies losing it just look for Meath v Louth on YouTube.
Re: News: My Perfect Cousin?
Posted by: hoddros (IP Logged)
Date: 15 July, 2010 22:54
Good article Phil. I have discussed these sorts of issues over a few pints for years, and never come up with anything brilliant as a solution.
I agree with GP relating to goal-line technology, within 4 seconds of the ball going over the line the Germans had broken away and nearly scored. They would have been livid if play had been stopped and the ball hadn't crossed the line.
The penalty goal seems sensible.
As for sin bins, I cannot agree. When teams lose a player now they almost always go into defensive mode and put all their players behind the ball. It makes for boring spectacles and would be even worse if it was happening throughout the game.
One thing that might improve attitudes of the players is to supply the referees with microphones as in rugby. It may be ugly at first but hopefully the players would be shamed into showing more restraint to the ref.
I agree with GP relating to goal-line technology, within 4 seconds of the ball going over the line the Germans had broken away and nearly scored. They would have been livid if play had been stopped and the ball hadn't crossed the line.
The penalty goal seems sensible.
As for sin bins, I cannot agree. When teams lose a player now they almost always go into defensive mode and put all their players behind the ball. It makes for boring spectacles and would be even worse if it was happening throughout the game.
One thing that might improve attitudes of the players is to supply the referees with microphones as in rugby. It may be ugly at first but hopefully the players would be shamed into showing more restraint to the ref.
Re: News: My Perfect Cousin?
Posted by: Phil. (IP Logged)
Date: 15 July, 2010 23:48
First things first, thank you, one and all, for taking the article in the spirit in which it was written. I did wonder if I would get a rake of anti-football diatribes, posting as I am on a rugby site.
I was vaguely aware of this technology didn't realise that it had been incorporated in top-level sport. Knocks my theory into a coked hat, especially with regard to the ball in play being "dead". Thank you.
I take your point and agree about the "miked-up" ref. Indeed, it's something that I should have addressed in my article. However, surely it's better for a team to go defensive rather than continuing kicking seven bells of whatever out of the opposition.
Quote:GP wrote...
The "was it a goal or wasn't argument" can be solved without the use of video evidence. Follow ice hockeys' example with a light on top of the goal. When the puck breaks the planes of the goal line, posts and cross-bar, the light is illuminated. sensors in the posts detect the passing of ONLY the puck over the goal line. The technology exists to change the sensors to recognise the shape and density of a football, as it's already been developed for one sport.
I was vaguely aware of this technology didn't realise that it had been incorporated in top-level sport. Knocks my theory into a coked hat, especially with regard to the ball in play being "dead". Thank you.
Quote:hoddros
As for sin bins, I cannot agree. When teams lose a player now they almost always go into defensive mode and put all their players behind the ball. It makes for boring spectacles and would be even worse if it was happening throughout the game.
One thing that might improve attitudes of the players is to supply the referees with microphones as in rugby. It may be ugly at first but hopefully the players would be shamed into showing more restraint to the ref.
I take your point and agree about the "miked-up" ref. Indeed, it's something that I should have addressed in my article. However, surely it's better for a team to go defensive rather than continuing kicking seven bells of whatever out of the opposition.
Re: News: My Perfect Cousin?
Posted by: DorsetSaint (IP Logged)
Date: 16 July, 2010 00:18
Interesting points! Often interested how rugby can learn from other sports and vice versa.
Penalty goals would not work in football imo. Controversy would reign supreme, referees would be under intolerable pressure from both sides, and it wouldn't prevent the Suarez incident from happening. It works in rugby, but the culture is entirely different in football. Suarez was sent off, a penaly awarded and Suarez banned from the semi - I think that's good enough.
The ice hockey example is interesting to resolve the goal line debate, or the incident could just be reviewed whenever the ball next went dead, maybe allied to some sort of challenge system as per American Football. I also think key offsides could be included in this. I don't think it would be that difficult to do - and what does it matter if referrals or video technology is not available on Hackney Marshes?
Don't like sin binning either, I think play acting to get others booked would just intensify. Howard Webb should have issued second yellows & reds at least once in the first half and was too soft (incredible considering the number of cards he ended up giving out)!
Referee mics have been tried before in football (early nineties if I remember with David Ellery). Tony Adams certainly wasn't shamed into modifying his language!!
I saw the Meath-Louth Leinster final as well! And they have judges behind the goal as well - something else FIFA thinks may cure goal line controversy!!
Agree football timing would be better if they used the rugby system of timing.
And you know what, I can't think of anything rugby can adopt from football either!
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 16/07/2010 00:20 by DorsetSaint.
Penalty goals would not work in football imo. Controversy would reign supreme, referees would be under intolerable pressure from both sides, and it wouldn't prevent the Suarez incident from happening. It works in rugby, but the culture is entirely different in football. Suarez was sent off, a penaly awarded and Suarez banned from the semi - I think that's good enough.
The ice hockey example is interesting to resolve the goal line debate, or the incident could just be reviewed whenever the ball next went dead, maybe allied to some sort of challenge system as per American Football. I also think key offsides could be included in this. I don't think it would be that difficult to do - and what does it matter if referrals or video technology is not available on Hackney Marshes?
Don't like sin binning either, I think play acting to get others booked would just intensify. Howard Webb should have issued second yellows & reds at least once in the first half and was too soft (incredible considering the number of cards he ended up giving out)!
Referee mics have been tried before in football (early nineties if I remember with David Ellery). Tony Adams certainly wasn't shamed into modifying his language!!
I saw the Meath-Louth Leinster final as well! And they have judges behind the goal as well - something else FIFA thinks may cure goal line controversy!!
Agree football timing would be better if they used the rugby system of timing.
And you know what, I can't think of anything rugby can adopt from football either!
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 16/07/2010 00:20 by DorsetSaint.
Re: News: My Perfect Cousin?
Posted by: Mattysaint (IP Logged)
Date: 16 July, 2010 11:20
Quote:Phil.Quote:Mattysaint
The national football team doesn't play at the same time as the club sides. Can you imagine what Ferguson would be like if England started taking Rooney away in November, February and March to play in a series of internationals while United were fighting for the league title?
Flip side is you can't have it boths ways and which do you prefer to have priority - club or country? Premiership title or World Cup?
Ah, but the Premiership (RU) has the play-offs which means that it is not imperative to finish top of the pile at the end of the regular season. Well done, Chelsea, you have finished top but now you have to play Spurs for the right to play the winners of Utd or Arsenal for the title. Can't see that happening...
Sorry for late reply! Doesn't the removal of key players durng a season put even a top 4 finish at risk though? For the EPS players they could be missing 4-6 Prem games during international windows next season, plus enforced rest weekends. That is a big chunk of the season, potentially 24-30 points or more at stake. Huge respect to Tigers who manage to overcome this every year.
Not trying to be contorversial, honest! Just thought this might be one possible negative from rugby's side of things compared to football.
Flip side is England RU made it to last 2 world cup finals, winning one. So again it's down to preference of club or country.
Re: News: My Perfect Cousin?
Posted by: Brushie (IP Logged)
Date: 16 July, 2010 11:38
As a former part-time rugby follower, that watches much more since my son took up the game, there are two things that I don't necessarily like with regard to pro-rugby.
Firstly, I'm old-school and therefore believe that the side that has finished top of the league should be crowned accordingly & not have to play a further two games to win it. They may have finished the season several points clear, only losing one or two games along the way and finishing several points clear of the rest, only to see 4th place snatch the title.
Secondly, and I think this could very much impact on the Saints, the loss of so many key players during the AI's & 6N, even if none of them pick up injuries, could be telling come the end of the season. I really think that all Premiership fixtures should be cancelled whenever theres a clash with Internationals, but I guess this would only add to an already congested fixture timetable.
Firstly, I'm old-school and therefore believe that the side that has finished top of the league should be crowned accordingly & not have to play a further two games to win it. They may have finished the season several points clear, only losing one or two games along the way and finishing several points clear of the rest, only to see 4th place snatch the title.
Secondly, and I think this could very much impact on the Saints, the loss of so many key players during the AI's & 6N, even if none of them pick up injuries, could be telling come the end of the season. I really think that all Premiership fixtures should be cancelled whenever theres a clash with Internationals, but I guess this would only add to an already congested fixture timetable.
Re: News: My Perfect Cousin?
Posted by: ChrisG (IP Logged)
Date: 16 July, 2010 13:19
Two most successful English sides of recent years, Tigers and Wasps had the bulk of players in the England squad. As said on another thread, logic says you are affected by losing international players but in reality the argument doesn't seem to exactly be borne out and perhaps that is reflected in our recruitment.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
