News: Tigers Tamed
Posted by: ComeOnYouSaints.com (IP Logged)
Date: 06 September, 2010 07:19
What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.
Re: News: Tigers Tamed
Posted by: OldPete (IP Logged)
Date: 06 September, 2010 07:33
You tell 'em Malcom - just what i thought too.
Re: News: Tigers Tamed
Posted by: SAINT_aitch (IP Logged)
Date: 06 September, 2010 07:42
And the pleasure of writing this particular match report, Malc. I can see the smile across your face now.
Well writ sir.
Well writ sir.
Re: News: Tigers Tamed
Posted by: StBleach (IP Logged)
Date: 06 September, 2010 08:10
Yep, good report Malcom - I will enjoy the E Mails and Txt messages from my leicester colleagues this morning. Also, I reckon that Mujati should play ahead of Murray - he never has a bad game and is always available. Murray is a good squad player imho.
Re: News: Tigers Tamed
Posted by: Ian Spokes (IP Logged)
Date: 06 September, 2010 10:31
Well I'm happy, especially as I was concerned about this particular fixture.
I hope nobody does 'turn on' Stephen Myler. After the first two kicks at the posts he had a bad day - it happens.
It does, however, present an interesting problem for the management as to who starts at 10 for the visit to the Stoop because Shane Geraghty looks to have recovered his lost form. Similarly, it would be hard on Brian Mujati if Euan Murray came straight back into the tight head slot, but perhaps they are going to rotate them come what may.
Overall a very good performance by Saints with some outstanding contributions throughout the team.
However, as you mention it Malcolm, I did think the multiple substitutions (and the timing of them and the particular choices) was a very strange decision indeed.
I hope nobody does 'turn on' Stephen Myler. After the first two kicks at the posts he had a bad day - it happens.
It does, however, present an interesting problem for the management as to who starts at 10 for the visit to the Stoop because Shane Geraghty looks to have recovered his lost form. Similarly, it would be hard on Brian Mujati if Euan Murray came straight back into the tight head slot, but perhaps they are going to rotate them come what may.
Overall a very good performance by Saints with some outstanding contributions throughout the team.
However, as you mention it Malcolm, I did think the multiple substitutions (and the timing of them and the particular choices) was a very strange decision indeed.
Re: News: Tigers Tamed
Posted by: LaurieK (IP Logged)
Date: 06 September, 2010 12:37
Excellent report, Howlin, with the right amount of realism. It was a fantastic win against a fantastic team. You cannot bemoan the loss of a bonus point on a day like yesterday. Win, take the four points and be happy, as you say.
One player not mentioned for outstanding play for me was Mr Wilson. Tremondous.
What was amazing was the pace that Saints played. We did not always play precisely and we did not play for 80 minutes but when we were good we were very good.
For me Shine has to stay and so does the Mooj.
And a final thought. I cannot remember a game of such quality, importance and intensity where Bruce, Bruce, Bruce played so little part. It is a real sign that we are moving forward when we do not rely on him to lead and to spark the big plays.
One player not mentioned for outstanding play for me was Mr Wilson. Tremondous.
What was amazing was the pace that Saints played. We did not always play precisely and we did not play for 80 minutes but when we were good we were very good.
For me Shine has to stay and so does the Mooj.
And a final thought. I cannot remember a game of such quality, importance and intensity where Bruce, Bruce, Bruce played so little part. It is a real sign that we are moving forward when we do not rely on him to lead and to spark the big plays.
Re: News: Tigers Tamed
Posted by: DorsetSaint (IP Logged)
Date: 06 September, 2010 13:08
Great report Howlin, agree with the lot - except the bit about the contest being effectively over after 5 mins - I never ever thought that!
Re: News: Tigers Tamed
Posted by: Howlin (IP Logged)
Date: 06 September, 2010 15:57
I can understand that you didn't think it at the time DS, neither did I (I worry when we are 20 points up with five mins to go !) but with the benefit of hindsight it was. They were hit with two quick tries, 14-0 down, and they never recovered remaining two scores behind right to the bitter end.
Saint til I die
Saint til I die
Re: News: Tigers Tamed
Posted by: DE Jones (IP Logged)
Date: 06 September, 2010 17:00
The problem with Murray is that even if he's second choice (but Mujati was 1st choice at the end of last season so its not a debate) he's not there on the bench on Sundays. The season's a marathon not a sprint (as the Saints discovered last season) and the need to share the workload is paramount. Its also RWC this time next year and a long season for the international players like Hartley, Lawes and less importantly the backs. Its noticeable the difference in policy between the AP and the ML, most of the ML internationals who toured last summer have not even played in a warm up, meanwhile our guys have had warm ups and a full on game, the subs were a bit late going on in my view. I now know why Leicester had the near 40 year old Mefin as 1st choice hooker last season, it was their failing in the line-out that knocked them back, yes the Saints forwards did well to disrupt but over and above that there were so many inaccurate throws at crucial times.
It was obviously a pretty strange anti-slope game, Leicester seemed to have won the toss and, don't know why, chose to play down the slope in the 1st half and, unusually, most of the tries were scored at the Sturtridge end. Maybe it was their policy to use the slope and wind to silence the crowd in the first 10 mins or so, then play the game, it certainly failed if that was the case.
dej
It was obviously a pretty strange anti-slope game, Leicester seemed to have won the toss and, don't know why, chose to play down the slope in the 1st half and, unusually, most of the tries were scored at the Sturtridge end. Maybe it was their policy to use the slope and wind to silence the crowd in the first 10 mins or so, then play the game, it certainly failed if that was the case.
dej
Re: News: Tigers Tamed
Posted by: St.Rich Joe, Niamh and Sam's Dad (IP Logged)
Date: 06 September, 2010 19:07
Re: News: Tigers Tamed
Posted by: Saint Cobbler (IP Logged)
Date: 06 September, 2010 19:18
Spot on report, optimism for the new season confirmed after the fun but mickey mouse friendlies. It helped that the Tigers lost Flood, but we won well without depending on a good kicker ourselves, and Shane showed quality qhich was lacking most of last season. Bring 'em on!!
Re: News: Tigers Tamed
Posted by: Howlin (IP Logged)
Date: 06 September, 2010 20:57
An "anti-slope game". I can see that phrase entering the coaching manual collection of classic quotes.
(or possibly my book of inane comments)
Saint til I die
(or possibly my book of inane comments)
Saint til I die
Re: News: Tigers Tamed
Posted by: St Marlowe (IP Logged)
Date: 07 September, 2010 00:35
Quote:DEJ
most of the ML internationals who toured last summer have not even played in a warm up, meanwhile our guys have had warm ups and a full on game,
...and pray, where would we bust the salary cap to acquire the cover which we cannot afford?
David L
What if there were no hypothetical questions?
- Live wrong and preposterously
Re: News: Tigers Tamed
Posted by: hoddros (IP Logged)
Date: 07 September, 2010 14:55
Great report thanks Malcolm.
I too was very happy overrall. It was a tremendous performance against the top club in the country.
However, I have to admit to being concerned at the time when we didn't go for the 5 yard scrum but went for the 3 points instead. Unfortunately I also had Sturat Barnes telling us all it was an unadventurous decision; and I did agree. Five minutes later Tigers had a similar opportunity and went for it, albeit the scoreline dictated that they had to, they scored a try. With them down to 14 I saw it at the time as an opportunity to maintain momentum. We surrendered that and Tigers grabbed it. That would be my only gripe, hopefully you will allow me just the one?
I too was very happy overrall. It was a tremendous performance against the top club in the country.
However, I have to admit to being concerned at the time when we didn't go for the 5 yard scrum but went for the 3 points instead. Unfortunately I also had Sturat Barnes telling us all it was an unadventurous decision; and I did agree. Five minutes later Tigers had a similar opportunity and went for it, albeit the scoreline dictated that they had to, they scored a try. With them down to 14 I saw it at the time as an opportunity to maintain momentum. We surrendered that and Tigers grabbed it. That would be my only gripe, hopefully you will allow me just the one?
Re: News: Tigers Tamed
Posted by: Howlin (IP Logged)
Date: 07 September, 2010 16:01
You may be right Ken , but it's all ifs and buts isn't it ? If they had gone for the scrum and not scored a try (highly likely) Tigs could have gone on to secure a bonus point. Denying what hopefully will be one of our top four opponents a point is just as valuable as securing a bonus point ourselves. Also players have to make the decisions in the heat of the game and instantly. They are not always going to make the right ones, certainly they won't always make decisions that everybody agrees with; that's impossible. Surely one of the attractions of sport is the unpredictability ?
Saint til I die
Saint til I die
Re: News: Tigers Tamed
Posted by: tedge (IP Logged)
Date: 07 September, 2010 18:24
Good report Howlin and for a change I find myself agreeing with most of what you say, even though I tend to be a glass half empty type to the extent that I worry about early successes in a game because I'm always afraid it might lead to complacency ! Like a few others my only quibble is about mass substitutions - they rarely seem to achieve anything positive and frequently the opposite.
Re: News: Tigers Tamed
Posted by: Bish01 (IP Logged)
Date: 07 September, 2010 18:35
Howlin' please get out of my head.
100% spot on with your outlook on The Saints.
I made several posts defending Shane and Smyler last year.
While others chose to jeer Smyler on Sunday (yes, o.k. you pays yer money yer takes yer choice blah blah) I really felt for the guy.
How many of those who jeered him have played at fly-half for The Saints? - virtually none of them so shut the heck up - you are not qualified to comment (nor am I having been a humble Saints Colts second row who soon realised that playing fast bowling in league cricket was immeasurably easier than playing rugby so my career ended as quickly as it began).
We have been treated royally in recent years and I steadfastly refuse to berate the team (or individual players) because of that.
I know that win or lose when I stand on the terrace I am about to be entertained - and yes,that includes our great encounters with Sarries last season.
Shane and Smyler have their detractors for different reasons.I said on the terrace after the Mooj's try - set up by Shane- that if Shane missed two penalties soon after that try the 'fickle element' would be on his back within minutes of cheering him to the rafters - it makes me sick.
Although I appreciate we need an all-round ten who can kick run and pass at the right time I will never be one of those detractors.
For the meantime my season ticket is my equivalent of buying the final, golden Wonka Bar.
100% spot on with your outlook on The Saints.
I made several posts defending Shane and Smyler last year.
While others chose to jeer Smyler on Sunday (yes, o.k. you pays yer money yer takes yer choice blah blah) I really felt for the guy.
How many of those who jeered him have played at fly-half for The Saints? - virtually none of them so shut the heck up - you are not qualified to comment (nor am I having been a humble Saints Colts second row who soon realised that playing fast bowling in league cricket was immeasurably easier than playing rugby so my career ended as quickly as it began).
We have been treated royally in recent years and I steadfastly refuse to berate the team (or individual players) because of that.
I know that win or lose when I stand on the terrace I am about to be entertained - and yes,that includes our great encounters with Sarries last season.
Shane and Smyler have their detractors for different reasons.I said on the terrace after the Mooj's try - set up by Shane- that if Shane missed two penalties soon after that try the 'fickle element' would be on his back within minutes of cheering him to the rafters - it makes me sick.
Although I appreciate we need an all-round ten who can kick run and pass at the right time I will never be one of those detractors.
For the meantime my season ticket is my equivalent of buying the final, golden Wonka Bar.
Re: News: Tigers Tamed
Posted by: SaintsDuncan (IP Logged)
Date: 07 September, 2010 19:41
Quote:Howlin
If they had gone for the scrum and not scored a try (highly likely) Tigs could have gone on to secure a bonus point.
Quite right Howlin, however, if we wish to be a consistantly top team/Prem title contender I feel it's times like that we need to stamp our mark on a game.
I'm all for the pragmatic choices (Munster away protecting the LBP for example) but could you imagine a Martin Johnson led Tigers taking the three there?
Re: News: Tigers Tamed
Posted by: St.Rich Joe, Niamh and Sam's Dad (IP Logged)
Date: 07 September, 2010 20:24
Sorry Duncan? I can't imagine MJ not taking the three.
No alcohol for January. I'm a dryathlete in aid of cancer research.
Dryathlon
No alcohol for January. I'm a dryathlete in aid of cancer research.
Dryathlon
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.


