Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: shizlebot (IP Logged)
Date: 11 October, 2010 08:23
And for our part in the process I think we have to remember that these guys are probably more frustrated than we are that the ball is not regularly going through the posts.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 11/10/2010 08:24 by shizlebot.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 11/10/2010 08:24 by shizlebot.
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: Sarge (IP Logged)
Date: 11 October, 2010 22:48
Leaving aside all the very valid points made above, how much difference did the change to an Adidas ball make for the Heinekin Cup game? Bruce, Shane and one of the Castres kickers all missed some kicks off the tee that should have been relatively straghtforward.
It has been said in the past that the Mitre ball previously used for European games had a different sweet spot to the Gilbert ball used in the Premiership. Has Adidas taken over Mitre, or is it a completely new ball for this year?
It has been said in the past that the Mitre ball previously used for European games had a different sweet spot to the Gilbert ball used in the Premiership. Has Adidas taken over Mitre, or is it a completely new ball for this year?
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: Saint Swill (IP Logged)
Date: 12 October, 2010 00:35
There is a counter-argument to the constant refinement of technique.
In 1991, Ian Baker-Finch won the Open Championship at Royal Birkdale with final rounds of 64 and 66. It was a sudden and unheralded rise to fame, but Baker-Finch cemented his improvement by three good runner-up slots shortly after.
This should have been the launchpad to a glittering career, but in a quest to improve his swing, Baker-Finch employed a series of experts to refine his technique. Every expert added his two-pennyworth. Stand closer to the ball, grip the club a little higher, stand back from the ball, loosen your grip, faster on the follow-through, slower on the downswing, relax the shoulders, tighten the wrists - the advice came thick and fast, and in pursuit of the perfect swing Baker-Finch took it all on board.
The result? The steepest plummet in form ever witnessed in top-class golf.Within a couple of years his game totally fell apart. By 1995/1996, he was disqualified or missed the cut or walked out of the 29 PGA tournaments he played in.
He retired in 1997 after shooting 92 in the first round of the Open and walking away. When questioned about it much later, he said that he listened to too much advice and applied so many tweaks to his swing that in the end he lost his "muscle memory" - the point where the subconscious takes over and controls the action to the point where repetition is automatic. He was simply thinking too much about what he was doing.
I'm not arguing against altering technique, simply suggesting there may some risks inherent in too much coaching.
In 1991, Ian Baker-Finch won the Open Championship at Royal Birkdale with final rounds of 64 and 66. It was a sudden and unheralded rise to fame, but Baker-Finch cemented his improvement by three good runner-up slots shortly after.
This should have been the launchpad to a glittering career, but in a quest to improve his swing, Baker-Finch employed a series of experts to refine his technique. Every expert added his two-pennyworth. Stand closer to the ball, grip the club a little higher, stand back from the ball, loosen your grip, faster on the follow-through, slower on the downswing, relax the shoulders, tighten the wrists - the advice came thick and fast, and in pursuit of the perfect swing Baker-Finch took it all on board.
The result? The steepest plummet in form ever witnessed in top-class golf.Within a couple of years his game totally fell apart. By 1995/1996, he was disqualified or missed the cut or walked out of the 29 PGA tournaments he played in.
He retired in 1997 after shooting 92 in the first round of the Open and walking away. When questioned about it much later, he said that he listened to too much advice and applied so many tweaks to his swing that in the end he lost his "muscle memory" - the point where the subconscious takes over and controls the action to the point where repetition is automatic. He was simply thinking too much about what he was doing.
I'm not arguing against altering technique, simply suggesting there may some risks inherent in too much coaching.
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: AlanSaints (IP Logged)
Date: 12 October, 2010 09:29
Lets take Munster - O'Gara is one of the worlds best kickers out of hand and to goal..did they win on Sunday...No. You don't have to have the worlds best kicker in your team to win the premiership and the Heineken cup. I thought Geraghty got us into really good positions on Friday and it was others in the team that made mistakes that followed. Apart from Carter (even he misses kicks) there is no other fly half that offers both the attacking flair and top class kicking. I am really worried that if Geraghty leaves the club after this season we will lose that momentum of going forward and attacking style rugby that got us to where we were last season. We all know what we were like before last season and I really don't want us to go backwards. We need to stick with Geraghty and accept the way he plays. I thought he looked like he was getting back to his old brilliant self on Friday night. Not sure what is going on with the forwards, they don't seem quite in tune. The ball was very slow coming from the breakdown and we all know how difficult it is to play behind a pack that are struggling. Hopefully Bruce has got over his mare. What I find very interesting is if Geraghty was Bruce on Friday night this messgaeboard would be full of negativity against Geraghty. If you want a topic to talk about, how about the srcum, the lineout???
Oh and has anyone found out if Nitro Warrior is a relation of Myler..or even Myler himself!! Now....there's a story!!
Oh and has anyone found out if Nitro Warrior is a relation of Myler..or even Myler himself!! Now....there's a story!!
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: Clegthorpe (IP Logged)
Date: 12 October, 2010 10:28
Quote:Sarge
It has been said in the past that the Mitre ball previously used for European games had a different sweet spot to the Gilbert ball used in the Premiership. Has Adidas taken over Mitre, or is it a completely new ball for this year?
It's a new ball for this competition. From what seems to be an Adidas press release on another site:
In addition, through positioning the valve in the seam and not in the middle of a panel, there is an enhanced sweet spot area ideal for kicking. With such an array of technical innovations, the adidas Tornado Respect is the perfect ball for the biggest club competition in world rugby.
I am not qualified to contribute to this discussion, but note the following kicking stats from Round 1:
Bath 40%
Blues 37.5%
Perpignan 57%
Sarries 40%
Leinster 55.6%
Tigers 57.1%
Saints 37.5%
Castres 33.3%
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: ClaireJ (IP Logged)
Date: 12 October, 2010 21:00
One of Ian Baker-Finch's claims to fame is hitting the ball from the 1st tee on the Old Course across the 1st and 18th fairways straight through the open window of the Russacks Hotel's Breakfast Room.
That's a huge distance and one helluva hook...
No wonder he thought his coaches had got it so wrong.
ClaireJ
RedHatPhoto.com review of 2015 photos here...
Buy photos from RedHatPhoto
That's a huge distance and one helluva hook...
No wonder he thought his coaches had got it so wrong.
ClaireJ
RedHatPhoto.com review of 2015 photos here...
Buy photos from RedHatPhoto
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: Howlin (IP Logged)
Date: 13 October, 2010 17:23
Those are staggering stats Clegthorpe. AlanSaints , I agree wholeheartedly re Geraghty and the forwards against Castres. They were in a tough fight, about that, there should be no doubt.
There are many that appear to believe Saints are world beaters after a good performance and then think they are doomed to failure after a less than perfect performance (win or lose!) and often translate these thoughts to individual players. Then they get upset when you disagree with them and appear to believe their views are being censored in some way when you do.
Well good luck to them. I subscribe to neither opinion and think we have a very good, young squad and one of the best management teams around. I watch my rugby in hope not expectation and above all usually enjoy the experience whatever the result.
Saint til I die
There are many that appear to believe Saints are world beaters after a good performance and then think they are doomed to failure after a less than perfect performance (win or lose!) and often translate these thoughts to individual players. Then they get upset when you disagree with them and appear to believe their views are being censored in some way when you do.
Well good luck to them. I subscribe to neither opinion and think we have a very good, young squad and one of the best management teams around. I watch my rugby in hope not expectation and above all usually enjoy the experience whatever the result.
Saint til I die
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
