Re: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: Ha! Wasn't Me (IP Logged)
Date: 09 October, 2010 23:37
R.E. the quiet, it's been ages - to my ears anyway - since EVERYBODY shut up (and there wasn't a tv blaring from a corporate box). It could be where I'm sat, but I was getting it at the end of last season too and I had a different seat then.
So, hey, I'm Dylan Hartley and I'm confrontational.
My Flickr and Picasa.
So, hey, I'm Dylan Hartley and I'm confrontational.
My Flickr and Picasa.
Re: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: Robby Richmond (IP Logged)
Date: 09 October, 2010 23:54
can i nominate ginge for that post being turned into an article?
Re: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: Ginger Prince in Stockholm (IP Logged)
Date: 10 October, 2010 10:00
That's very kind of you Robby, thanks.
And thank you to the editors, too, for your swift work.
Ginger - The Colour of Sexual Rejection
And thank you to the editors, too, for your swift work.
Ginger - The Colour of Sexual Rejection
Re: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: Johnno2 (IP Logged)
Date: 10 October, 2010 10:27
Agree with this - we should be expecting a world class kicking coach to have an impact on how the kickers cope under pressure.
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: St Owen (IP Logged)
Date: 10 October, 2010 10:34
Both Bruces' and Myler's kicking styles have changed significantly over the seasons. Is it wise to make such wholesale changes to a kickers style when it can affect there performance to such a degree?
You can't always get what you want, But if you try sometimes well you might find, You get what you need.
Richards/Jagger
You can't always get what you want, But if you try sometimes well you might find, You get what you need.
Richards/Jagger
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: Toulousian Firefighter (IP Logged)
Date: 10 October, 2010 11:18
I'm pretty sure Shane changed his style mid-way through last season and i think it's changed this season too. He seems to have a run and swipe at it at times.
Can someone explain to me the positioning of the ball? When I've kicked before, I'd try different placings but they'd usually involve tilting it slightly towards me or to the post. I saw that one of Shane's on Friday was tilted heavily towards the Church's stand. These guys are the experts but I can't help but think that, if his foot doesn't strike 100% of the sweet spot, the power going through the ball is going to take the ball off the tee in a very unpredictable manner. But we haven't seen that happen (3 times) so far this season, have we?
Can someone explain to me the positioning of the ball? When I've kicked before, I'd try different placings but they'd usually involve tilting it slightly towards me or to the post. I saw that one of Shane's on Friday was tilted heavily towards the Church's stand. These guys are the experts but I can't help but think that, if his foot doesn't strike 100% of the sweet spot, the power going through the ball is going to take the ball off the tee in a very unpredictable manner. But we haven't seen that happen (3 times) so far this season, have we?
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: OldPete (IP Logged)
Date: 10 October, 2010 11:56
thanks GP - a very sensible piece indeed.
I have never kicked a ball at the posts ( and i wonder how many of the armchair critics have ) - I wouldnt know where to start - so i cant imagine what it must be like to have to do this with 13,000 expectant fans watching and judging ones efforts.
I have never kicked a ball at the posts ( and i wonder how many of the armchair critics have ) - I wouldnt know where to start - so i cant imagine what it must be like to have to do this with 13,000 expectant fans watching and judging ones efforts.
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: Ginger Prince in Stockholm (IP Logged)
Date: 10 October, 2010 13:39
To answer a few questions raised,
Johnno2 – The only “real” world class kicking coach is Dr Dave Alred, who worked with the England team up to (and maybe just beyond) the 2003 RWC. His doctorate was earned in the analysis of the kicking action (and comparison to golf swing) – the action being an inverted “J” (the backswing of the leg by contracting hamstring muscles being the loop, the downswing, contact and follow-through being the “stem”).
A lot of what the current kicking coaches, Callard (at England level) for example, are using his work as theirs – after all, Dave Alred has worked with a lot of high quality players in his career (Grayse being and student (97 Lions), and of course, Jonny as his protégé – when his father paid for the coaching during Jonnys’ schooldays).
Alred had time to work his with players to help refine – maybe what’s happening here is that we don’t have time during the season (the kickers are a work in progress – and this is a long process). I think that’s why we are quick to judge without any thought of what is actually going on terms of where the players are along the refinement process, and mentally – not trusting yourself when you know your kicking style is not the finished article – what do you do? Come back to what you know, i.e. kick like you did before…
If you want to address the kicking under pressure, you’d be combining the kicking coaching with a sport psychologist. The mental approach to kicking could be addressed in another “Ginger seminar”…
St Owen - you're right about Bruza changing his kicking style, but I believe that was a necessity (remember the clean-out knee surgery he had done not that long ago?). Sometimes the change in style is due to injuries inhibiting movement, other times the exact opposite - Jonny had a problem with his groin after he re-modelled his kicking action, that turned out to be a previously unused (and therefore under-strength) muscle being involved in the new kicking action. The incessant practice regime Jonny had made the groin worse - the price being side-lined again.
I'm not sure whether "wholesale" changes have been made. It's a tricky thing to balance, overloading the player with all the corrective measures at once, or drip feeding them in a logical sequence. There is a knock-on effect when one element is changed, as it disrupts the previously autonomous process.
Try to imagine the skill broken down into 4 component parts;
1 - approach; angle and distance from the ball
2 - balance; position of standing foot relative to the ball, head position, body alignment (standing leg and hip braced), leading arm and shoulder movement
3 - contact; the correct part of the foot hitting the sweet spot (of the sweet spot) on the ball
4 - follow through to the intended finish point
Change any one of those, and the whole process begins to "crumble". The approach dictates, the balance, which dictates the contact, and so on. So the attention to detail shown by Grayse has to be exact and minimise errors further along the kicking action – it sounds a little silly; you can’t tweak things too much as you have a desired outcome, but want to have that as often as possible, with minimal disruption.
TF – If I recall correctly, Geraghty changed his kicking style at the behest of the England coaching staff (Callard). This in itself could create a conflict of interest if Callard and Grayse have differing opinions on how best to help him. Whether it’s too much information, or just the wrong information, it’s counter-productive to what the aim of the coaching is.
There are some more obvious flaws in his action, but over time, can be refined. I prefer not to list them here as I don’t want to turn this thread into “this player can’t do that” or show any bias toward any player.
The placing of the ball at angle is to expose the sweet spot to the kicker. The sweet spot is about a third of the way up the ball. Striking through here, the balls then rolls over its axis. You’ll know you’re someway there when you kick as you achieve what looks like backspin on the ball. Kick too high, (centre of the ball) and the trajectory of the ball is flatter, and the flight path looks more “distressed”. The foot rising from the top of the loop (in the J) to the stem gives the ball its velocity and release angle.
When you think about it, even changing the tee, can have a detrimental effect – how many varieties are there at different heights, as well as those that “force” you to place the ball in a particular way due to their design?
It’s not so much the foot striking the sweet spot, more the 4 parts of the process synchronising and acting smoothly, one after the other. You can get away with not striking the sweet spot perfectly (some kicks do wobble over), and you’ll know a different sound when someone misses the sweet spot completely – the audible “thud” as opposed to the “pop”.
Ginger - The Colour of Sexual Rejection
Johnno2 – The only “real” world class kicking coach is Dr Dave Alred, who worked with the England team up to (and maybe just beyond) the 2003 RWC. His doctorate was earned in the analysis of the kicking action (and comparison to golf swing) – the action being an inverted “J” (the backswing of the leg by contracting hamstring muscles being the loop, the downswing, contact and follow-through being the “stem”).
A lot of what the current kicking coaches, Callard (at England level) for example, are using his work as theirs – after all, Dave Alred has worked with a lot of high quality players in his career (Grayse being and student (97 Lions), and of course, Jonny as his protégé – when his father paid for the coaching during Jonnys’ schooldays).
Alred had time to work his with players to help refine – maybe what’s happening here is that we don’t have time during the season (the kickers are a work in progress – and this is a long process). I think that’s why we are quick to judge without any thought of what is actually going on terms of where the players are along the refinement process, and mentally – not trusting yourself when you know your kicking style is not the finished article – what do you do? Come back to what you know, i.e. kick like you did before…
If you want to address the kicking under pressure, you’d be combining the kicking coaching with a sport psychologist. The mental approach to kicking could be addressed in another “Ginger seminar”…
St Owen - you're right about Bruza changing his kicking style, but I believe that was a necessity (remember the clean-out knee surgery he had done not that long ago?). Sometimes the change in style is due to injuries inhibiting movement, other times the exact opposite - Jonny had a problem with his groin after he re-modelled his kicking action, that turned out to be a previously unused (and therefore under-strength) muscle being involved in the new kicking action. The incessant practice regime Jonny had made the groin worse - the price being side-lined again.
I'm not sure whether "wholesale" changes have been made. It's a tricky thing to balance, overloading the player with all the corrective measures at once, or drip feeding them in a logical sequence. There is a knock-on effect when one element is changed, as it disrupts the previously autonomous process.
Try to imagine the skill broken down into 4 component parts;
1 - approach; angle and distance from the ball
2 - balance; position of standing foot relative to the ball, head position, body alignment (standing leg and hip braced), leading arm and shoulder movement
3 - contact; the correct part of the foot hitting the sweet spot (of the sweet spot) on the ball
4 - follow through to the intended finish point
Change any one of those, and the whole process begins to "crumble". The approach dictates, the balance, which dictates the contact, and so on. So the attention to detail shown by Grayse has to be exact and minimise errors further along the kicking action – it sounds a little silly; you can’t tweak things too much as you have a desired outcome, but want to have that as often as possible, with minimal disruption.
TF – If I recall correctly, Geraghty changed his kicking style at the behest of the England coaching staff (Callard). This in itself could create a conflict of interest if Callard and Grayse have differing opinions on how best to help him. Whether it’s too much information, or just the wrong information, it’s counter-productive to what the aim of the coaching is.
There are some more obvious flaws in his action, but over time, can be refined. I prefer not to list them here as I don’t want to turn this thread into “this player can’t do that” or show any bias toward any player.
The placing of the ball at angle is to expose the sweet spot to the kicker. The sweet spot is about a third of the way up the ball. Striking through here, the balls then rolls over its axis. You’ll know you’re someway there when you kick as you achieve what looks like backspin on the ball. Kick too high, (centre of the ball) and the trajectory of the ball is flatter, and the flight path looks more “distressed”. The foot rising from the top of the loop (in the J) to the stem gives the ball its velocity and release angle.
When you think about it, even changing the tee, can have a detrimental effect – how many varieties are there at different heights, as well as those that “force” you to place the ball in a particular way due to their design?
It’s not so much the foot striking the sweet spot, more the 4 parts of the process synchronising and acting smoothly, one after the other. You can get away with not striking the sweet spot perfectly (some kicks do wobble over), and you’ll know a different sound when someone misses the sweet spot completely – the audible “thud” as opposed to the “pop”.
Ginger - The Colour of Sexual Rejection
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: desbralass (IP Logged)
Date: 10 October, 2010 15:52
GP,what an excellent and informative article.Thank you,I've learnt something about kicking.
And I do agree with OP regarding having never kicked a ball...I don't knock what I can't do myself.
Bridesmaids no more.
And I do agree with OP regarding having never kicked a ball...I don't knock what I can't do myself.
Bridesmaids no more.
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: desbralass (IP Logged)
Date: 10 October, 2010 16:06
Robby...hubby asks...was Grayse playing for Waterloo that day?
Bridesmaids no more.
Bridesmaids no more.
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: ajack (IP Logged)
Date: 10 October, 2010 17:05
A good article from GP, however the reference to Woods is inaccurate as he actually won three events in 1997 after his first master’s win following the first of his many swing changes.
Whilst I don’t doubt for one minute that you sometimes need to take a step back in order to eventually move forward, I am still not sure where the forward steps come in terms of the Saints kicking coaches.
I repeat the question who was the last player that improved (dramatically) as a kicker whilst being coached at Saints?
Whilst I don’t doubt for one minute that you sometimes need to take a step back in order to eventually move forward, I am still not sure where the forward steps come in terms of the Saints kicking coaches.
I repeat the question who was the last player that improved (dramatically) as a kicker whilst being coached at Saints?
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: Robby Richmond (IP Logged)
Date: 10 October, 2010 17:20
erm, matt dawson?
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: Ginger Prince in Stockholm (IP Logged)
Date: 10 October, 2010 17:23
Ajack, my apologies - I meant MAJOR tournament wins, not merely tour titles after the 97 masters.
The question I have to preface your is who have been the kicking coaches in recent years, if anyone?
I assume that Grayse is doing that job in his current role, but previously? Can't think who Solomons or Smith employed, and i wasn't connected to the club or town prior to 2001
Ginger - The Colour of Sexual Rejection
The question I have to preface your is who have been the kicking coaches in recent years, if anyone?
I assume that Grayse is doing that job in his current role, but previously? Can't think who Solomons or Smith employed, and i wasn't connected to the club or town prior to 2001
Ginger - The Colour of Sexual Rejection
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: Robby Richmond (IP Logged)
Date: 10 October, 2010 17:36
frank ponasi was the skills coach that was apparently to blame for pretty much everything when we went down....
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: ajack (IP Logged)
Date: 10 October, 2010 18:39
Rob I would give you Daws as he joined as an 18? year old kid it is fair to say his kicking improved while at Saints.
However as he left in 2004? That is something like six years with no real improvement, not a great return is it?
However as he left in 2004? That is something like six years with no real improvement, not a great return is it?
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: Robby Richmond (IP Logged)
Date: 10 October, 2010 18:55
quite agree pal,
digger worked really hard on his field kicking, improved it to such a point he is now comfortably able to play full back.
We all loved sharky but in 100 appearances for the club how many times did you ever see him box kick?
dyl has worked really hard on his throwing, and is now top class,
we can pick holes in things all night, it all comes back to the phrase, there is no such thing as a complete player.
without wishing to sound derogitry and disrespectful in any way, bedford do not practice field kicking.
does that sound daft to anyone else? perhaps they dont have enough time in the training schedule?
thinking aloud on a forum, this wont end well...
digger worked really hard on his field kicking, improved it to such a point he is now comfortably able to play full back.
We all loved sharky but in 100 appearances for the club how many times did you ever see him box kick?
dyl has worked really hard on his throwing, and is now top class,
we can pick holes in things all night, it all comes back to the phrase, there is no such thing as a complete player.
without wishing to sound derogitry and disrespectful in any way, bedford do not practice field kicking.
does that sound daft to anyone else? perhaps they dont have enough time in the training schedule?
thinking aloud on a forum, this wont end well...
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: Ben_D (IP Logged)
Date: 10 October, 2010 22:46
I understand the mechanical concepts and the theories surrounding muscle memory, technique etc.
However there is an equally important element that hasn't been covered and that's the mental approach. Wilkinson under the tutelage of Alred dedicated just as much time to the mental aspects and visualisation of the kicking process as he did to the mechanics.
Citing golf is a good example as so much of the process is carried out between the ears. Teaching kicking psychology is probably the hardest aspect of the whole process and I remain to be convinced that the problem remains entirely mechanical for our boys - one in particular.
However there is an equally important element that hasn't been covered and that's the mental approach. Wilkinson under the tutelage of Alred dedicated just as much time to the mental aspects and visualisation of the kicking process as he did to the mechanics.
Citing golf is a good example as so much of the process is carried out between the ears. Teaching kicking psychology is probably the hardest aspect of the whole process and I remain to be convinced that the problem remains entirely mechanical for our boys - one in particular.
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: ballagher (IP Logged)
Date: 10 October, 2010 23:17
Quote:ajack
I repeat the question who was the last player that improved (dramatically) as a kicker whilst being coached at Saints?
Is your question rhetorical Ajack and, if so, is that because it's screamingly obvious (not to me)? Or is the point you're making that noone can remember when it last happened? Or is it one of those trivia questions that's usually answered by Smurf (or, before Simon, Mark H) in no time at all?
If it's a genuine question that you want the answer to (and you're ruling out Matt Dawson; coached by Paul Grayson I add mischievously) I'd say Paul Grayson (but I can't believe that's what you want to be the answer).
Since Grayson was the mainstay (Hepher and Townsend in and out during that time); there's been Drahm, Reihana, Spencer, Myler and Geraghty.

Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: DorsetSaint (IP Logged)
Date: 11 October, 2010 00:14
The mechanical aspects described here are interesting and informative, but I agree with Ben_D in that I really think it's more a mental issue. Can we over-analyse the mechanics sometimes? I know it sounds ignorant and simplistic, but it's just kicking a ball over a bar - it's really not that difficult away from the pressures of the game/crowd/match situation. I know because I can do it, and if I can do it, it's not too difficult. It's a lot simpler than, say, mastering the complexities of a golf swing. The difference is i'm not paid to do it, and there's not 13,500 people watching me and many more on telly et etc. For all the great posts here, I still don't know how you get over that pressure aspect?
The only feeble suggestion I have is to switch the thought process regularly when things are not going well. If you missing then make the dominant thought something else during the kicking process.
For example, if you are thinking technique during the kick, switch to focussing on one of the uprights and drawing/fading it in from there and forget technique - just focus on that upright and let instincts take over regarding technique. Once I went through a spell of imagining a patch of grass where I wanted to land the ball beyond the posts and almost forgot about the posts completely. I also went through a spell of trying the clear the crossbar by only what was required and nothing more (ie just dinking it over in some cases). It sounds a recipe for diasaster but it's funny how it really seemed to help as it was a way of getting into the frame of mind of just mucking about on the training pitch rather than a game situation.
Whatever, the thoughts, I find there tends to be a dominant one during the act of kicking and changing this around from time to time when things start to go awry might help. Sometimes it might take the warm up before a game to figure what thought process feels comfortable and works for you on the day and it may well vary from game to game.
Just a rambling thinking out loud post - sorry!
The only feeble suggestion I have is to switch the thought process regularly when things are not going well. If you missing then make the dominant thought something else during the kicking process.
For example, if you are thinking technique during the kick, switch to focussing on one of the uprights and drawing/fading it in from there and forget technique - just focus on that upright and let instincts take over regarding technique. Once I went through a spell of imagining a patch of grass where I wanted to land the ball beyond the posts and almost forgot about the posts completely. I also went through a spell of trying the clear the crossbar by only what was required and nothing more (ie just dinking it over in some cases). It sounds a recipe for diasaster but it's funny how it really seemed to help as it was a way of getting into the frame of mind of just mucking about on the training pitch rather than a game situation.
Whatever, the thoughts, I find there tends to be a dominant one during the act of kicking and changing this around from time to time when things start to go awry might help. Sometimes it might take the warm up before a game to figure what thought process feels comfortable and works for you on the day and it may well vary from game to game.
Just a rambling thinking out loud post - sorry!
Re: News: They're not bad kickers
Posted by: ChrisG (IP Logged)
Date: 11 October, 2010 08:13
Perhaps we need to strip it all back, go back to basics and build from there, I sometimes think re kicking some of the exponents are getting blinding by science, told to try this and that technique from various different people (sometimes conflicting) to improve their stats but having them fall apart in the process. If everyone was mentally and physically the same there may been some hard and fast rules to thae art but they aren't and maybe people should be encouraged to develop what they are comfortable and happy with rather than striving for something that is clearly at times upsetting their natural kicking technique and in time other aspects of their game.
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.
