The End of the Game for Gentlemen


Just another scandal?
By Kevin Jones
August 28 2009

Rugby has often been described as a game for hooligans played by gentlemen by the football fraternity while football is a game for gentlemen played by hooligans regarded by Rugby fans, and rugby union fans have looked down their noses at football and its highly paid stars and scandals. But just what has happened to Rugby over the last two years? Is it on the slippery slope to WWF-style mockery?

Lets look at the evidence. First of all let’s start with the latest scandal or ‘Bloodgate’ as it has now become known. AS you all will know, during the Heineken Cup quarter-final between Harlequins and Leinster, winger Tom Williams, who had replaced the injured outside half Nicky Evans was led from the field with blood gushing from his mouth. A heavily strapped Evans returned to attempt a drop goal which would have put Quins in the semi-final. All of those watching the game on Sky sports along with Barnsey gasped at the stupidity of Williams who, when leaving the field smiled and winked at Evans. The blood according to the camera's eye looked obviously fake. It has come to light that this is common practice throughout the Premiership according to Mr Richards.  

Eye gouging

There has also been a significant rise in eye gouging, Munster flanker Alan Quinlan missed out on the Lions tour to South Africa because of an incident in the Heineken Cup, Springbok Schalk Burger was banned for eight weeks after the second test with the Lions, a sentence he shared with Italian captain Sergio Parisse for a similar offence in Italy’s test with the All Blacks. Northampton’s new recruit Neil Best was handed a ban for so called "eye contact", and in 2007 another Northampton "Saint" Dylan Hartley received a 6 month ban. 

Drinking and Drug Taking ‘M Lady’

Mike Tindall was banned from driving for three years after failing a breath test the morning after a trip to the races then Bath hit the headlines with a series of drug problems confirming why it’s called the ‘Recreation ground’. Matt Stevens was banned from rugby for two years after admitting taking Cocaine. Three other players, Michael Lipman, Andrew Higgins and Alex Crockett resigned from the club after refusing to take drug tests.  Australian international Justin Harrison was banned for eight months for taking Cocaine but has since retired. 

Liar Liar

Possibly the weirdest story and 1st prize for out and out stupidity goes to  Mattieu Bastareaud. The Stade Francais centre suffered a suspected fractured eye socket and facial cuts after a night out in Wellington following France’s 2nd test loss against the All Blacks. Bastareaud told  Wellington Police that he had been the victim of an assault by up to five men but later admitted that he’d fallen over his bedroom table whilst drunk. This episode almost cost France a war with New Zealand which only dissipated after the French Prime Minister apologized to his New Zealand counterpart. Le Pillock!!  

‘When I said nail the hooker I was talking about the All Blacks’

And now we come to the sex scandals. Topsy Ojo, Mike Brown and Danny Care were the subject of accusations of sexual impropriety by a teenage girl during a tour of New Zealand which later became unsubstantiated as the victim never came forward to make a formal complaint and all charges were dropped, never the less two of the three players were fined and reprimanded (Danny Care was completely exonerated) and no doubt Martin Johnston gave them a good kick up the backside on their return before he officially took the reigns of the England squad which also saw a new code of conduct introduced for future tours.  

Fake Tans, Big Boobs and Spitting the Dummy

We all know about Henson and his teammates Lee Byrne, Mike Phillips and Andy Powell creating a scuffle at the pub opposite the Millennium Stadium after Wales beat England but spare a thought for poor old Katherine Jenkins after admitting that she took cocaine and ecstasy which ended up costing her gigs as the mascot of the Welsh Rugby Union. As for publicly spitting the dummy, as well as Henson England has their own toy thrower in Mr Cipriani. 

A Bit of Rough and Tumble

Another worrying shift is a number of players on charges for assault - Olly Barkley and Lesley Vainikolo being the latest high-profile examples up before the beak.  

The Conclusion
 

With the Olympics around the corner and sevens being a nominated sport for 2012 this type of press is as welcome as swine flu. With players becoming household names and celebrities, staying out of the limelight is becoming more and more difficult.

But let’s put it all into perspective and take a positive from all of this, at least the powers that be are now sitting up and taking notice and at least look like attempting to put the Rugby house in order.  This season all eyes are on the Premiership just waiting for something else to make a story about. Lets show them that the amateur ethos of CAN still exist in professional sport, and make this season and every season after that better and better, and show that, while it has had some serious issues to overcome, that this sport deserves it’s place in the Olympics.

(Edited by Andy Brown)

The End of the Game for Gentlemen
Posted by: TykesRugby.co.uk (IP Logged)
Date: 28/08/2009 19:23

What do you think? You can have your say by posting below.
If you do not already have an account Click here to Register.

Re: The End of the Game for Gentlemen
Posted by: Mark_C (IP Logged)
Date: 28/08/2009 20:58

Can the Club game survive in the same sphere as the PROFESSIONAL game?

Re: The End of the Game for Gentlemen
Posted by: Bran (IP Logged)
Date: 29/08/2009 09:20

not in my opinion. The vast amounts of money invovled mean the players have to be paid more and more. with more money comes more temptation. This comes at younger and younger ages due to the development of players mentally and physically. What you cant get earlier though is expeirience every one of us will have done things in our youth and looked back and questioned our reasoning. Christ I have nights like that now although I'm more likley to think I should have done it not I shouldn't have!

Re: The End of the Game for Gentlemen
Posted by: Wildwillie (IP Logged)
Date: 29/08/2009 12:42

I agree with Bran. Money inevitably corrupts - it is human nature. We are a greedy species!

Re: The End of the Game for Gentlemen
Posted by: apb (IP Logged)
Date: 29/08/2009 18:12

I must point out that the original article didn't make it clear that Danny Care was exonerated of all charges. My apologies to Danny and his family - the error was entirely mine.

Waiting for the good times ...

..and waiting ....


... and waiting ...

Re: The End of the Game for Gentlemen
Posted by: Jonah (IP Logged)
Date: 30/08/2009 22:34

It now appears England Rugby may be under investigation regarding cheating during the six nations, when will it end!!

Quick to judge
Quick to anger
Slow to understand

Ignorance and prejudice
and fear walk hand in hand

Re: The End of the Game for Gentlemen
Posted by: Timofe (IP Logged)
Date: 31/08/2009 00:28

I wonder if Diccon (and his counterparts around the country) include dealing with the media and how to avoid scandal in their Academy training sessions? If not, they should.

Suffering on the Leeds and Yorkshire roller-coaster since 2001

Re: The End of the Game for Gentlemen
Posted by: Plumgarth (IP Logged)
Date: 31/08/2009 12:23

Symptom of professional sport I am afraid.

Drugs in rugby league
Drugs in RU
Drugs in Swimming, athletics, football, cyling

Cheating rife in football

Everyone is looking for an edge or just trying to survive the pressure. Where ever there is money and ego you will find cheats on and off the sports arena.

I dont know why everyone pretends to be shocked. Everytime you have a tradesman in your house they cheat you, every time you buy a car you get ripped off, buy a house and you might as well burn money because you are a sitting target for the solicitor and the bank.

Cheating, fraud, legal scams are a fact of Britain so why should sport be any different.

If you can find an answer you will be a millionaire.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2009:08:31:12:25:36 by Freddy Quinlan.

Re: The End of the Game for Gentlemen
Posted by: J6/7 (IP Logged)
Date: 31/08/2009 18:12

Its a bit harsh to cite the lads who were never charged for any misdemeanour - bit like poor old Bobby Moore in South America! Also, some people have been known to falsify stories, remember Gerhard Berger & Barry Sheene in Oz!

But generally, cheating is rife in sport, business and (especially) government! However, as all dodgy dishonest politicians are aware, we never seem to remember or learn from all this @#$%&! everything blows over and we just accept it... look at the lying, devious downright fraudalent moves pulled by our MPs and local councilours, not only are they (MPs) still earning megabuck salaries, but not one has been charged with fraud - just imagine if you claim to be unemployed and do a job for cash, you would end up with a criminal record! (if caught, no mercy would be shown, no handing it back etc)

They just rely on the fact that the peculiar nature of the UK native involves forgetting all the scandals as soon as they have disappeared off the front pages of the newspapers, and this phenomina will also apply to squalid rugby miscreants!

It is only the real supporters who are beating theirselves up over this issue - no one else gives a toss.

Re: The End of the Game for Gentlemen
Posted by: Bobba (IP Logged)
Date: 01/09/2009 07:44

Some amount of coaching of the players, whether accademy or first team, should be part of the development of players. They are, after all,in the shop window of the Club. The same applies to ticket office staff... Anyone in the club who has contact with the general public or the media should have this type of coaching.
However, to coach specifically to avoid scandal becomes obsolete if the club is clean.

Re: The End of the Game for Gentlemen
Posted by: Mark_C (IP Logged)
Date: 01/09/2009 08:21

"It is only the real supporters who are beating theirselves up over this issue - no one else gives a toss.".

Sorry, but I disagree with the above. If it is true then it will be the "rapidly dwindling number of real supporters". If the game is to expand it needs all the credible publicity it can get. The antics of the Harlequins staff and management have dealt a massive blow to the standing of Rugby Union in the public arena. The game's authorities must take a step back to guage the damage, and act accordingly.

Re: The End of the Game for Gentlemen
Posted by: Plumgarth (IP Logged)
Date: 01/09/2009 11:00

I agree with this but I see the symptoms of what have gone on running a lot deaper. There needs to be some serious soul searching across society in general and a committment to sort these issues out.

Re: The End of the Game for Gentlemen
Posted by: Rocky's Dad (IP Logged)
Date: 01/09/2009 11:04

Thank God the season starts this weekend and we can stop talking about what’s wrong with Rugby and start enjoying what’s right with it.

I for one will be pleased to be reading about the 2009\10 season and not the last one.

Let’s hope we all enjoy Sunday.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 2009:09:01:11:34:06 by Rocky's Dad.

Re: The End of the Game for Gentlemen
Posted by: Bran (IP Logged)
Date: 01/09/2009 11:17

rocky's dad, although I agree with you 100%, this cannot be allowed to dissappear just yet. The latest posting on the BBc website show's just how far they have gone to try and get away with the whole thing. Preassurizing a doctor to cut his mouth with a scalpell and she felt she had to comply to keep her position? This is appauling and the more I read the more I feel Quins have gotten away very very lightly! I have worked for some right b*****s in my job, but that goes with the job to some degree. I'm not saying its right but part of the job, and no where near as bad as when I first came into the trade. But this is a sport that has always prtraid certain standards how very wrong they were.

Sorry, you do not have permission to post/reply in this forum.
We record all IP addresses on the Sportnetwork message boards which may be required by the authorities in case of defamatory or abusive comment. We seek to monitor the Message Boards at regular intervals. We do not associate Sportnetwork with any of the comments and do not take responsibility for any statements or opinions expressed on the Message Boards. If you have any cause for concern over any material posted here please let us know as soon as possible by e-mailing abuse@sportnetwork.net